If you're the kind of foodie who finds joy in discovering comfort food done right, Bonello’s New York Pizza is a delicious detour you won't regret. Let’s start with the stars of the show — the pizzas. The Pepperoni Slice is a classic love letter to NYC-style pizza, with that perfect foldable crust, crispy edges, and pepperoni slices that curl and crisp in all the right ways. The Cheese Slice? It’s a gooey, golden slice of nostalgia. For those who want a bit more control, the One Item Pizza and Two Items Pizza options let you customize your flavor fix without overwhelming the pie.
But Bonello’s doesn’t stop at pizza. Their sandwiches are serious contenders. The Meatball Sandwich is a saucy, melty masterpiece — each bite layered with tender meatballs, rich marinara, and warm bread that soaks it all in. The Sausage & Pepper Sandwich hits with bold, rustic flavors, while the Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich is a vegetarian triumph, crunchy outside and tender inside, all smothered in cheese. Craving something hefty? The Torpedo Sandwich is the go-big-or-go-home pick. And don’t overlook the Sausage Sandwich — simple, satisfying, and unapologetically hearty.
To balance it all, the Italian dishes offer classic comfort. The House Salad is fresh and crisp, a perfect light start. The Mostaccioli is baked pasta bliss, bubbling with cheese and robust tomato sauce. For antipasto lovers, the Antipasto Salad and its elevated version with Sausage deliver on flavor and variety. Add a side of Garlic Bread — because no Italian meal is complete without it.
Bonello’s menu feels like a warm hug from a New York Italian kitchen — authentic, filling, and made with love. Come hungry, leave happy.